Niles Harrison Pfeiffer

Niles Harrison Pfeiffer Central Florida REALTOR®

$610,000.00
243 S CENTRAL AVENUE, UMATILLA, FL - 32784
3 beds
2.5 baths
1,961 sqft
$610,000.00
243 S CENTRAL AVENUE, UMATILLA, FL - 32784
Niles Harrison Pfeiffer
$610,000.00
3 beds
2.5 baths
1,961 sqft
243 S CENTRAL AVENUE, UMATILLA, FL - 32784
For Sale
Photo 1
  • Built in 1875
  • $311.07/sqft
  • Lot size: 1.63 acres
  • 106 days on market

Unique Lakefront Colonial with Pool & Guest House in Downtown Umatilla Built in 1875, this rare colonial-style home is full of character and old-world charm—truly not a cookie-cutter house. Set on 1.63 acres directly on Lake Umatilla, it features a private dock with electric service, boat lift, and jet ski lift. The main home offers 3 bedrooms and 2 baths, with a downstairs suite and two bedrooms upstairs sharing a full bath. Distinctive details include 10-foot ceilings, crown molding, vintage glass doorknobs, and a working vintage-style elevator. The detached 1-bedroom, 1-bath guest house with attached workshop would be a great rental or small business. The cottage adds an additional 1000 square feet. Recent updates include: Electrical, Plumbing, Kitchen; downstairs bathroom; exterior paint, roof (2018), and front windows; plus New Hot water heater. Perfect for entertaining, you can host gatherings by the pool, grill on the deck, and enjoy boating, fishing and skiing on the lake. Zoned Residential/Professional, this property also offers potential for a home-based business or office. Convenient to Umatilla Airport, with the occasional seaplane landing right on the lake.

  • Directions: From Umatilla, travel south on State Route 19 Home is on left.
  • County: Lake
  • Geo subdivision: ACREAGE & UNREC

Nearby Schools

Umatilla Elem

Umatilla Middle

Umatilla High

Features

Financial

Let's get in touch!

Niles Harrison Pfeiffer

Niles Harrison Pfeiffer

Central Florida REALTOR®

See also

For Sale
20018 BILL COLLINS ROAD, EUSTIS, FL - 32736
$585,000.00
4 bds
2.0 ba
2,284 sqft
20018 BILL COLLINS ROAD, EUSTIS, FL - 32736
For Sale
40145 W 7TH AVENUE, UMATILLA, FL - 32784
$645,000.00
4 bds
2.5 ba
2,347 sqft
40145 W 7TH AVENUE, UMATILLA, FL - 32784
For Sale
43411 STATE ROAD 19, ALTOONA, FL - 32702
$599,000.00
2 bds
2.0 ba
2,204 sqft
43411 STATE ROAD 19, ALTOONA, FL - 32702
Stellar MLS
  • Source: Stellar MLS
  • MLS #: G5107014
Listing updated: May 2, 2026 at 4:05PM
Listing provided by: John Whipple, VANGIE BERRY SIGNATURE REALTY
Last checked 2 days ago
IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website.