Niles Harrison Pfeiffer

Niles Harrison Pfeiffer Central Florida REALTOR®

$3,700,000.00
4649 NEW BROAD STREET, ORLANDO, FL - 32814
5 beds
5.5 baths
5,411 sqft
$3,700,000.00
4649 NEW BROAD STREET, ORLANDO, FL - 32814
Niles Harrison Pfeiffer
$3,700,000.00
5 beds
5.5 baths
5,411 sqft
4649 NEW BROAD STREET, ORLANDO, FL - 32814
For Sale
Photo 1
  • Built in 2008
  • 3 garage spaces
  • $683.79/sqft
  • Lot size: 15,563 sqft
  • 5 days on market

Framed by mature oaks and set along Baldwin Park’s iconic main boulevard, this stately custom home and former Parade of Homes winner offers a truly exceptional setting overlooking a serene park and picturesque pond with a cascading waterfall. A classic columned façade and welcoming brick-paver front porch lead to a gracious entry, opening into an impressive living room anchored by a Beautiful gas fireplace. Just off the entry, a handsome first-floor study features extensive millwork, custom built-ins, and an ensuite bath, offering flexibility as a private guest suite or fifth bedroom. Designed for both everyday living and entertaining, the home flows seamlessly from space to space. The beautifully renovated kitchen is a true centerpiece, featuring a rare blue quartzite island, refined cabinetry, designer lighting, and a full suite of premium Dacor appliances. The kitchen opens to a spacious family room and casual dinette, while a separate formal dining room provides an ideal setting for more formal gatherings. A dedicated theater room with plush leather recliners, a newer Sony theater projector, and updated surround sound adds to the home’s versatility. The first-floor primary suite offers a private retreat with dual walk-in closets and an enviable ensuite bath finished in marble and complemented by all new lighting and fixtures. Upstairs, three additional bedrooms and fully renovated bathrooms showcase marble finishes, custom glass enclosures, and elevated fixtures throughout. A spacious loft-style living area adds another layer of flexibility, complete with custom cabinetry and a wet bar—perfect as a secondary lounge, game room, media space, or private retreat. Outdoor living is equally impressive, with a covered rear lanai featuring a fireplace and wood-paneled ceiling, overlooking a recently resurfaced saline pool and spa, surrounded by lush, professionally designed landscaping. Extensive upgrades provide peace of mind, including a newer roof, multiple HVAC systems with transferable warranties, updated pool equipment, smart home integration, enhanced security, and more. Please see the attached upgrades sheet for a full list of recent renovations and improvements. All of this, ideally located within Baldwin Park—one of Orlando’s most sought-after communities—offering top-rated schools, parks, three community pools, and a vibrant downtown with dining, shopping, and everyday conveniences just moments away. This is a rare chance to own a signature custom residence in one of Baldwin Park’s most coveted locations—private showings available by appointment!

  • Directions: From the intersection of State Road 50/West Colonial Drive, turn north onto Bennett Road, right on New Broad Street, make a u-turn on Common Way and the home is on the right hand side.
  • County: Orange
  • Geo subdivision: BALDWIN PARK UT 01 50 121

Nearby Schools

Baldwin Park Elementary

Glenridge Middle

Winter Park High

Features

Financial

Let's get in touch!

Niles Harrison Pfeiffer

Niles Harrison Pfeiffer

Central Florida REALTOR®

See also

For Sale
207 E KINGS WAY, WINTER PARK, FL - 32789
$3,650,000.00
5 bds
4.5 ba
3,719 sqft
207 E KINGS WAY, WINTER PARK, FL - 32789
For Sale
1751 GLENCOE ROAD, WINTER PARK, FL - 32789
$3,490,000.00
5 bds
6.0 ba
4,520 sqft
1751 GLENCOE ROAD, WINTER PARK, FL - 32789
For Sale
1581 FOREST AVENUE, WINTER PARK, FL - 32789
$3,495,000.00
4 bds
5.0 ba
4,683 sqft
1581 FOREST AVENUE, WINTER PARK, FL - 32789
Stellar MLS
  • Source: Stellar MLS
  • MLS #: O6402857
Listing updated: May 1, 2026 at 3:52PM
Listing provided by: Farah Bloom, KELLER WILLIAMS WINTER PARK
Last checked 17 hours ago
IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website.