Niles Harrison Pfeiffer

Niles Harrison Pfeiffer Central Florida REALTOR®

$2,995,000.00
1204 NOTTINGHAM STREET, ORLANDO, FL - 32803
5 beds
5.0 baths
3,689 sqft
$2,995,000.00
1204 NOTTINGHAM STREET, ORLANDO, FL - 32803
Niles Harrison Pfeiffer
$2,995,000.00
5 beds
5.0 baths
3,689 sqft
1204 NOTTINGHAM STREET, ORLANDO, FL - 32803
For Sale
Photo 1
  • Built in 2026
  • 2 garage spaces
  • $811.87/sqft
  • Lot size: 13,196 sqft
  • 40 days on market

A REFINED CUSTOM SINGLE-STORY RESIDENCE WITH CASITA BY M. LAHR HOMES! Located in the highly sought-after Beverly Shores / Rose Isle neighborhood of Orlando / Winter Park, this newly completed custom residence represents a rare opportunity in one of Central Florida’s most desirable and seldom-available areas. This home reflects the level of craftsmanship, detail, and execution that has made the builder one of the most respected names in Winter Park and Orlando luxury construction. Thoughtfully designed as a large single-story residence, the main home offers an expansive beautifully planned living space with 4 bedrooms, a private office, 4.5 baths, and a layout that balances scale, functionality, and everyday livability. Adding to the rarity of the offering is the casita / secondary living space, creating exceptional flexibility for guests, extended family, private work space, or additional lifestyle needs. From the moment of arrival, the home conveys a sense of timeless design and quality. Inside, the experience is defined by a clean, cohesive aesthetic and a level of finish that is simply not typical in today’s new construction market. Every element, from the architectural lines to the material selections, has been intentionally executed, resulting in a home that feels both elevated and enduring. The floor plan is open and highly functional, with expansive living areas that transition seamlessly to the outdoor environment, creating a natural extension of the interior living space. The result is a home that lives comfortably day-to-day while offering the scale, presence, and design quality expected at this level. Opportunities in Beverly Shores / Rose Isle rarely present themselves, and large single-story custom homes with a casita are especially difficult to find. This is one of those moments. What ultimately sets this property apart is the consistency of its execution — a level of detail, craftsmanship, and finish quality that is rarely achieved, even among competing new construction offerings in Winter Park and Orlando. Located in a fantastic location in the highly desirable Audubon Park School K-8 School District. Minutes to Downtown Orlando, Downtown Winter Park, Winter Park’s Park Avenue, Winter Park Village, AdventHealth, ORMC, shopping, dining, and more. An exquisite luxury estate in one of Central Florida’s most dynamic and desirable areas!

  • Directions: From Mills Ave/1792 head East on Nottingham. Home is down on the right
  • County: Orange
  • Geo subdivision: BEVERLY SHORES

Nearby Schools

Audubon Park K8

Audubon Park K-8

Edgewater High

Features

Financial

Let's get in touch!

Niles Harrison Pfeiffer

Niles Harrison Pfeiffer

Central Florida REALTOR®

See also

For Sale
361 E KINGS WAY, WINTER PARK, FL - 32789
$3,199,000.00
4 bds
4.5 ba
3,737 sqft
361 E KINGS WAY, WINTER PARK, FL - 32789
For Sale
1236 CHICHESTER STREET, ORLANDO, FL - 32803
$2,950,000.00
5 bds
5.5 ba
3,501 sqft
1236 CHICHESTER STREET, ORLANDO, FL - 32803
For Sale
1581 FOREST AVENUE, WINTER PARK, FL - 32789
$3,275,000.00
4 bds
5.0 ba
4,683 sqft
1581 FOREST AVENUE, WINTER PARK, FL - 32789
Stellar MLS
  • Source: Stellar MLS
  • MLS #: O6425268
Listing updated: August 23, 2026 at 7:05PM
Listing provided by: Robert Kurzreiter PA, KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY AT THE PARKS
Last checked 1 day ago
IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website.